We scored Amazon's own ads
We pulled 13 active video ads that Amazon runs from its own Facebook pages (6 from Amazon.com and 7 from Prime Video) in the Meta Ad Library on 2026-11-18, and scored each one out of 100 with the same AI roast every ad on the Wall gets. Tap any ad to watch it and read the full roast.
The Amazon Prime page had no active US video ads when we pulled. Creator partnership ads that Amazon pays for but that run from a creator's own page are left out.
Amazon had no part in this page and does not endorse AdMaxxing.
All 13 live Wall ads from Amazon's own pages, highest score first. Scores are the latest AI roast on AdMaxxing, out of 100. The score is an AI critique of what a viewer sees in the ad. It does not measure how the ad performed.
Best and worst 2

Best
Prime Video
73/ 100
Cyberpunk aura maxxing with high budget visuals and zero explanation.
Craft 8/10: Crisp sound design and cinematic pacing fitted well into portrait mode.

Worst
Prime Video
31/ 100
Prime Video posted a twenty year old movie clip with zero branding and clocked out early.
Offer 1/10: No mention of where to watch, the title, or any subscription deal.
Every Amazon ad we scored 13

Prime Video
73/ 100
Cyberpunk aura maxxing with high budget visuals and zero explanation.
Offer 6/10: Streaming premiere date is clear but gives no reason to pre-save.

Prime Video
71/ 100
Peak sci-fi aura farming that forgets to give a reason to click today.
Offer 4/10: Only offers a future premiere date without a direct watch or trial perk.

Amazon.com
69/ 100
Celebrity mom aura carries a grocery ad that forgot to show actual prices.
Offer 4/10: Generic low prices claim without a specific promo, deal, or trial.

Prime Video
66/ 100
Giving away the entire fifty year old climax in vertical format is pure menace behavior.
Offer 4/10: Standard streaming push with no mention of release schedule or subscription terms.

Amazon.com
64/ 100
Kathryn Hahn carries an ad whose main selling point is colon health.
Offer 4/10: A generic slogan without specific savings or introductory deals.

Amazon.com
62/ 100
Mouthwatering food shots with zero actual price tags in sight.
Offer 4/10: Promises spending less but gives no prices, discounts, or specific deals.

Amazon.com
57/ 100
Kathryn Hahn got summoned for a six second side quest.
Offer 4/10: Low prices every day is as vague as it gets.

Prime Video
56/ 100
A romance montage that feels like a fan edit made in twenty minutes.
Offer 3/10: No release schedule, free trial, or special package mentioned.

Amazon.com
55/ 100
A clean stop motion unboxing that forgot to bring actual discounts.
Offer 3/10: States a date for the event but reveals no prices, percentages, or perks.

Prime Video
55/ 100
A kissing montage with notebook doodles trying to rizz up your watchlist.
Offer 3/10: No promo price or trial mentioned anywhere.

Amazon.com
54/ 100
A million dollar cinematic movie about bribing transit workers with cardboard boxes.
Offer 2/10: Zero promotions, delivery cutoff dates, or actual product deals listed.

Prime Video
53/ 100
A romance trailer that forgets to give its own title main character aura.
Offer 4/10: Telling the audience you are obsessed is not a value proposition.

Prime Video
31/ 100
Prime Video posted a twenty year old movie clip with zero branding and clocked out early.
Offer 1/10: No mention of where to watch, the title, or any subscription deal.
Touch point averages
Average score out of 10 across all 13 ads. Overall average 59/100.
- Hook6.6
- Clarity7.5
- Offer3.5
- Proof4.2
- Call to action4.3
- Craft7.5
What Amazon's ads do well
Across 13 ads, Amazon's average is 59/100, against 51/100 for every scored ad on the Wall. 6 of the 13 ads reach 60 or more. The strongest touch points are craft (an average of 7.5/10) and clarity (7.5/10).
The best ad is this Prime Video ad at 73/100. On craft it scores 8/10, and the roast says: “Crisp sound design and cinematic pacing fitted well into portrait mode.”
The hook weighs most, a quarter of the score, because an ad nobody stops for sells nothing. 6 of the 13 ads score 7 or more out of 10 on the hook, and the average is 6.6/10.
By page, Amazon.com averages 60 and Prime Video averages 58. Amazon.com leads and Prime Video trails by 2 points.
Where Amazon's ads lose points
The weakest touch points are offer (3.5/10) and proof (4.2/10). That is where most of the missing points go, and the note under each ad in the full list shows what the scorer said about offer for that ad.
The lowest score is this Prime Video ad at 31/100, 42 points under the best. On offer it scores 1/10, and the roast says: “No mention of where to watch, the title, or any subscription deal.”
Craft averages 7.5/10, so production is not what holds these ads back. The two cheapest fixes here are to give a concrete reason to act now, such as a price, a deal or a result, and to put a number, a review or a real customer on screen.
Score your own ad the same way
The same scorer reads your ad on the same six touch points. Upload a video ad on the Maxx page and see where it lands next to Amazon's.
Roast your own ad free
Upload a video ad and get the same score out of 100 on hook, clarity, offer, proof, call to action and craft, with the notes that explain each one.
Maxx my ad